Motivasi saya menulis ranking-rankingan seperti ini bukan demi
prestige semata, tapi juga untuk menggelorakan semangat '45 eh
semangat belajar buat semua orang Indonesia. Salah satu yang
memotivasi saya ya waktu saya nonton documentary film-nya Singapore
ketika memulai perjalanan republiknya di akhir tahun 50-an. Encik Lee
Senior saat itu bingung mau jadi apa/khawatir masa depan Singapore
ketika harus pisah dari Malaysia. Nyatanya kita liat sekarang fakta
bhw knowledge is power melalui Singapore. Jadi tidak salah kalo orang
Indonesia haus akan pendidikan yang berkualitas; berburu beasiswa.
Tidak salah kalo Bangsa Indonesia mulai serius dengan
pendidikannya.
Sebelumnya saya juga udah posting daftar universitas negara tertentu
yang 'diakui' oleh Singapore. Nah kalo yang satu ini daftar 400
universitas top dunia tahun 2007 yang dirilis oleh THES. Terlepas
dari kontroversi siapa lebih baik dari siapa, ranking-ranking seperti
ini setidaknya bisa jadi guidance mereka yang ingin melanjutkan
pendidikan tinggi di institusi yang dianggap berkualitas tinggi.
Belakangan, ranking yang dirilis Shanghai Jiaotong juga banyak
dikutip oleh universitas-universitas yang merasa ranking itu fair, US
Carnegie Mellon dan National US, misalnya.
Satu hal yang menonjol dari ranking yang dirilis THES ini, lebih
banyak uni dari UK yang bertengger di peringkat atas jika
dibandingkan dengan ranking yang dibuat Shanghai Jiaotong. Hal lain
yang menarik untuk dicermati adalah masalah diskrepansi urutan
peringkat antara ranking yang dibuat oleh satu lembaga dg ranking
yang dibuat oleh lembaga yang lain. Kita ambil US Carnegie Mellon,
menurut ranking yg dibuat US News, uni ini menempati ranking 40-an
dalam daftar mereka, sementara kita lihat sendiri dalam ranking di
bawah ini, Carnegie Mellon berada di nomor 20, sharing peringkat
dengan Cornell. Jika anda mencermati ranking-ranking ini dari tahun
ke tahun yang dibuat oleh berbagai institusi seperti THES, US News,
Business Week, Princeton, dll. cuman Duke University yang setia
menempati peringkat setelah 12 sebelum 14 :)
Dalam ranking di bawah ini, universitas-universitas top Indonesia
juga masuk daftar diantaranya Gadjah Mada University (UGM) yang
teratas di peringkat 360, disusul Bandung Institute of Technology
(ITB) di peringkat 369, dan University of Indonesia di nomor 395.
Kalo menurut saya, pastinya ranking ini adalah overall assessment
(beberapa kriteria) dari uni-uni yang masuk daftar dan bukan satu
atau dua kriteria/aspek/subject saja, misalnya teaching vs. research
quality, international faculty, ratio of professor:student, # papers
published in international journal, dll. Kalo subject/field yang
dijadikan acuan semata, maka Carnegie Mellon bisa dikatakan #1 in IT
subject.
Selamat berburu uni top :)
Iwan
Ranking-rankingan seperti ini bisa menimbulkan interpretasi dan
reaksi yang beragam. Salah satunya komentar yang dipsoting pembaca
saya rasa lucu tapi jujur (mungkin banyak yang secara sadar ataupun
tidak, berkomentar seperti orang ini):
"Mcgill is better than Stanford. Okay this ranking is nonsense.
oh boy..."
THES - QS World University Rankings 2007 - Top 400 Universities
Rank School Name Country
1 HARVARD University United States
2= YALE University United States
2= University of OXFORD United Kingdom
2= University of CAMBRIDGE United Kingdom
5 Imperial College LONDON United Kingdom
6 PRINCETON University United States
7= University of CHICAGO United States
7= CALIFORNIA Institute of Technology (Calt... United States
9 UCL (University College LONDON) United Kingdom
10 MASSACHUSETTS Institute of Technology (M... United States
11 COLUMBIA University United States
12 MCGILL University Canada
13 DUKE University United States
14 University of PENNSYLVANIA United States
15 JOHNS HOPKINS University United States
16 AUSTRALIAN National University Australia
17 University of TOKYO Japan
18 University of HONG KONG Hong Kong
19 STANFORD University United States
20= CORNELL University United States
20= CARNEGIE MELLON University United States
22 University of California, BERKELEY United States
23 University of EDINBURGH United Kingdom
24 King´s College LONDON United Kingdom
25 KYOTO University Japan
26 Ecole Normale Supérieure, PARIS France
27 University of MELBOURNE Australia
28 ÉCOLE POLYTECHNIQUE France
29 NORTHWESTERN University United States
30 University of MANCHESTER United Kingdom
31 The University of SYDNEY Australia
32 BROWN University United States
33= University of BRITISH COLUMBIA Canada
33= National University of SINGAPORE Singapore
33= University of QUEENSLAND Australia
36 PEKING University China
37 University of BRISTOL United Kingdom
38= The CHINESE University of Hong Kong Hong Kong
38= University of MICHIGAN United States
40 TSINGHUA University China
41 University of CALIFORNIA, Los Angeles (U... United States
42 ETH Zurich (Swiss Federal Institute of T... Switzerland
43 MONASH University Australia
44 University of NEW SOUTH WALES Australia
45 University of TORONTO Canada
46 OSAKA University Japan
47 BOSTON University United States
48 University of AMSTERDAM Netherlands
49 NEW YORK University (NYU) United States
50 The University of AUCKLAND New Zealand
51= SEOUL National University Korea, South
51= University of TEXAS at Austin United States
53= HONG KONG University of Science & Techno... Hong Kong
53= TRINITY College Dublin Ireland
55= University of WISCONSIN-Madison United States
55= University of WASHINGTON United States
57 University of WARWICK United Kingdom
58 University of CALIFORNIA, San Diego United States
59 LONDON School of Economics and Political... United Kingdom
60 HEIDELBERG University Germany
61 Katholieke Universiteit LEUVEN Belgium
62 University of ADELAIDE Australia
63 DELFT University of Technology Netherlands
64 University of WESTERN AUSTRALIA Australia
65= Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München (... Germany
65= University of BIRMINGHAM United Kingdom
67 Technische Universität MÜNCHEN Germany
68 University of SHEFFIELD United Kingdom
69 NANYANG Technological University Singapore
70 University of NOTTINGHAM United Kingdom
71= DARTMOUTH College United States
71= UPPSALA University Sweden
73 University of ILLINOIS United States
74= EMORY University United States
74= University of YORK United Kingdom
76 University of ST ANDREWS United Kingdom
77= PURDUE University United States
77= University of PITTSBURGH United States
79 University of MARYLAND United States
80= University of LEEDS United Kingdom
80= University of SOUTHAMPTON United Kingdom
82 VANDERBILT University United States
83 University of GLASGOW United Kingdom
84 LEIDEN University Netherlands
85= CASE WESTERN RESERVE University United States
85= FUDAN University China
85= University of VIENNA Austria
88 QUEEN´S University Canada
89 UTRECHT University Netherlands
90= PENNSYLVANIA STATE University United States
90= TOKYO Institute of Technology Japan
92 RICE University United States
93= University of MONTREAL Canada
93= University of COPENHAGEN Denmark
95 University of ROCHESTER United States
96 University of CALIFORNIA, Davis United States
97= GEORGIA Institute of Technology United States
97= University of ALBERTA Canada
99 CARDIFF University United Kingdom
100 University of HELSINKI Finland
101 University of LIVERPOOL United Kingdom
102= GEORGETOWN University United States
102= National TAIWAN University Taiwan
102= TOHOKU University Japan
105 University of GENEVA Switzerland
106 LUND University Sweden
107 University of COLORADO United States
108 MCMASTER University Canada
109 DURHAM University United Kingdom
110 University of VIRGINIA United States
111 MAASTRICHT University Netherlands
112= NAGOYA University Japan
112= University of WATERLOO Canada
114= University of BASEL Switzerland
114= University of OTAGO New Zealand
114= University of AARHUS Denmark
117= University of CALIFORNIA, Santa Barbara United States
117= Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de LAUSANNE... Switzerland
119 University of SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA United States
120 OHIO STATE University United States
121 University of SUSSEX United Kingdom
122 TEXAS A&M University United States
123 Université Catholique de LOUVAIN (UCL) Belgium
124 University of GHENT Belgium
125 NANJING University China
126= HUMBOLDT-Universität zu Berlin Germany
126= University of WESTERN ONTARIO Canada
128 Hebrew University of JERUSALEM Israel
129 NEWCASTLE University, NEWCASTLE Upon Tyn... United Kingdom
130= Technical University of DENMARK Denmark
130= EINDHOVEN University of Technology Netherlands
132= Université Pierre-et-Marie-Curie - PARIS... France
132= KOREA Advanced Institute of Science & Te... Korea, South
134 University of ARIZONA United States
135 University of FLORIDA United States
136 KYUSHU University Japan
137= University of ABERDEEN United Kingdom
137= INDIANA University Bloomington United States
139 SIMON FRASER University Canada
140= University of CALIFORNIA, Irvine United States
140= University of ZURICH Switzerland
142= University of MINNESOTA United States
142= Universität TÜBINGEN Germany
144 Universität FREIBURG Germany
145 University of BATH United Kingdom
146 Freie Universität BERLIN Germany
147 University of LANCASTER United Kingdom
148 WAGENINGEN University Netherlands
149= Queen Mary, University of LONDON United Kingdom
149= CITY University of Hong Kong Hong Kong
151= HOKKAIDO University Japan
151= TEL AVIV University Israel
151= University of NORTH CAROLINA United States
154 Université Libre de BRUXELLES (ULB) Belgium
155= University of NOTRE DAME United States
155= University of Science and Technology of ... China
157 Ecole Normale Supérieure de LYON France
158 CRANFIELD University United Kingdom
159= MICHIGAN STATE University United States
159= TUFTS University United States
161= KEIO University Japan
161= WASHINGTON University in St. Louis United States
163= SHANGHAI JIAO TONG University China
163= ERASMUS University Rotterdam Netherlands
165 Universität STUTTGART Germany
166= University of CALGARY Canada
166= VIENNA University of Technology Austria
168= Universität GÖTTINGEN Germany
168= MACQUARIE University Australia
170 HELSINKI University of Technology - TKK Finland
171= University of DUNDEE United Kingdom
171= Universität KARLSRUHE Germany
173= University of BOLOGNA Italy
173= University of GRONINGEN Netherlands
175= University of SAO PAULO Brazil
175= University of MASSACHUSETTS, Amherst United States
177= RUTGERS, The State University of New Jer... United States
177= University of CAMPINAS (Unicamp) Brazil
177= University College DUBLIN Ireland
180= WASEDA University Japan
180= University of READING United Kingdom
182 Rheinisch-Westfälische Technische Hochsc... Germany
183 Università degli Studi di ROMA - La Sapi... Italy
184 Université Louis Pasteur - STRASBOURG I France
185= University of LEICESTER United Kingdom
185= University of TWENTE Netherlands
187 University of ANTWERP Belgium
188= University of CANTERBURY New Zealand
188= University of OSLO Norway
190 University of SURREY United Kingdom
191 RENSSELAER Polytechnic Institute United States
192= KTH, ROYAL Institute of Technology Sweden
192= Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México ... Mexico
194 University of BARCELONA Spain
195= Radboud Universiteit NIJMEGEN Netherlands
195= QUEENSLAND University of Technology Australia
197= CHALMERS University of Technology Sweden
197= KOBE University Japan
199 University of WOLLONGONG Australia
200= University of CAPE TOWN South Africa
200= RMIT University Australia
202 University of MIAMI United States
203= WAKE FOREST University United States
203= Technische Universität BERLIN Germany
205= LA TROBE University Australia
205= QUEEN´S University of Belfast United Kingdom
207 University of IOWA United States
208 BRANDEIS University United States
209= Universität FRANKFURT am Main Germany
209= ZHEJIANG University China
209= University of TSUKUBA Japan
212 HIROSHIMA University Japan
213 University of VICTORIA Canada
214 University of BERN Switzerland
215 University of NEWCASTLE Australia
216 Universität HAMBURG Germany
217 University of LAUSANNE Switzerland
218 TULANE University United States
219 University of CINCINNATI United States
220 University of EXETER United Kingdom
221= ARIZONA STATE University United States
221= DALHOUSIE University Canada
223 CHULALONGKORN University Thailand
224 STONY BROOK University United States
225= University of BERGEN Norway
225= University of INNSBRUCK Austria
227= OTTAWA University Canada
227= Sciences Po PARIS France
229= GEORGE WASHINGTON University United States
229= Vrije University BRUSSELS (VUB) Belgium
231= TECHNION - Israel Institute of Technolog... Israel
231= Lomonosov MOSCOW STATE University Russia
233 POHANG University of Science and Technol... Korea, South
234 VICTORIA University of Wellington New Zealand
235 CURTIN University of Technology Australia
236 YONSEI University Korea, South
237= LOUGHBOROUGH University United Kingdom
237= University of TURKU Finland
239= SAINT-PETERSBURG State University Russia
239= Technische Universität DARMSTADT Germany
239= Pontificia Universidad Católica de CHILE... Chile
242 MASSEY University New Zealand
243= Technische Universität DRESDEN Germany
243= School of Oriental and African Studies, ... United Kingdom
243= KOREA University Korea, South
246= STOCKHOLM University Sweden
246= Universiti MALAYA (UM) Malaysia
248= NORTH CAROLINA STATE University United States
248= University of ATHENS Greece
248= Virginia Polytechnic Institute (VIRGINIA... United States
248= YORK University Canada
252 University of STRATHCLYDE United Kingdom
253 FLORIDA STATE University United States
254 University of DELHI India
255 University of HAWAII United States
256= DREXEL University United States
256= The HONG KONG Polytechnic University Hong Kong
258 Universidad Autònoma de BARCELONA Spain
259= University of CALIFORNIA, Santa Cruz United States
259= University of Technology, SYDNEY Australia
261 University of UTAH United States
262 University of LIEGE Belgium
263 Universität ULM Germany
264= University of BUENOS AIRES Argentina
264= University of TASMANIA Australia
266 ASTON Business School United Kingdom
267= KUOPIO University Finland
267= Université Paris-Sud, PARIS XI France
269 Indian Institute of Technology Bombay (I... India
270= Universität WÜRZBURG Germany
270= Universität ERLANGEN-NÜRNBERG Germany
272 University of ESSEX United Kingdom
273= NAGASAKI University Japan
273= STOCKHOLM School of Economics Sweden
275 Université Joseph-Fourier, GRENOBLE I France
276= Göteborg University Sweden
276= IOWA STATE University United States
276= Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universitä... Germany
279 Karl-Franzens-University GRAZ Austria
280 LAVAL University Canada
281 University of KANSAS United States
282= University of ALABAMA United States
282= University of the WITWATERSRAND South Africa
284= MAHIDOL University Thailand
284= CHIBA University Japan
286= WASHINGTON STATE University United States
286= University College CORK Ireland
286= BEN GURION University of the Negev Israel
289 University of TENNESSEE United States
290 CHARLES University Czech Republic
291 University of SOUTH AUSTRALIA Australia
292= University of TROMSO Norway
292= BRUNEL University United Kingdom
292= Universität LEIPZIG Germany
295= Université Paris-Sorbonne (PARIS IV) France
295= University of GEORGIA United States
297 Universität BAYREUTH Germany
298 University of CALIFORNIA, Riverside United States
299 UMEÅ University Sweden
300 DUBLIN City University Ireland
301= University of MONTPELLIER II - Sciences ... France
301= NORWEGIAN University of Science and Tech... Norway
303 College of WILLIAM & MARY United States
304= University of MANITOBA Canada
304= Vrije Universiteit AMSTERDAM Netherlands
306 Universidad Autónoma de MADRID Spain
307= Universiti Sains MALAYSIA (USM) Malaysia
307= Indian Institute of Technology Delhi (II... India
309= GRIFFITH University Australia
309= Universiti Kebangsaan MALAYSIA (UKM) Malaysia
311 Universität KONSTANZ Germany
312= Universidad de CHILE Chile
312= University of PADUA Italy
312= Universität DÜSSELDORF Germany
312= Universität BIELEFELD Germany
316 Universität JENA Germany
317 University of SOUTHERN DENMARK Denmark
318 SHOWA University Japan
319= University of COIMBRA Portugal
319= University of Cologne Germany
319= University of NAVARRA Spain
319= University of WAIKATO New Zealand
319= University of TAMPERE Finland
324 TIANJIN University China
325 University of PISA Italy
326 COLORADO STATE University United States
327 WHU Otto Beisheim School of Management -... Germany
328 University of CONNECTICUT United States
329 University of FLORENCE Italy
330 Johannes Gutenberg University MAINZ Germany
331= GUNMA University Japan
331= JAGIELLONIAN University Poland
333 Ruhr-Universität BOCHUM Germany
334 National TSING HUA University Taiwan
335 TOKYO Metropolitan University Japan
336= University of QUEBEC Canada
336= National CHENG KUNG University Taiwan
338 Federal University of RIO DE JANEIRO Brazil
339= Universitat POMPEU FABRA Spain
339= University of MÜNSTER Germany
341= Universität MARBURG Germany
341= Universidade Nova de LISBOA Portugal
343= University of DELAWARE United States
343= Politecnico di MILANO Italy
345= WARSAW University Poland
345= GIFU University Japan
345= SAARLAND University Germany
345= CARLETON University Canada
349 University of BRADFORD United Kingdom
350 LOYOLA University Chicago United States
351= DUBLIN Institute of Technology Ireland
351= University of OREGON United States
351= FLINDERS University Australia
354= YOKOHAMA NATIONAL University Japan
354= University of OULU Finland
356= National Technical University of ATHENS Greece
356= University of East Anglia (UEA) United Kingdom
358= City University of NEW YORK United States
358= University of NEW MEXICO United States
360= University of TOULOUSE III - Paul Sabati... France
360= Universitas GADJAH MADA Indonesia
362= University of ST GALLEN Switzerland
362= University of SOUTH CAROLINA United States
364= Universität BREMEN Germany
364= Science University TOKYO Japan
364= OSAKA CITY University Japan
364= Universiti Putra MALAYSIA (UPM) Malaysia
368 Johannes Kepler University LINZ Austria
369= BANDUNG Institute of Technology Indonesia
369= Université PARIS I - Panthéon Sorbonne France
371= LINKÖPING University Sweden
371= WARSAW University of Technology Poland
373 University of OKLAHOMA United States
374= DEAKIN University Australia
374= University of JYVÄSKYLÄ Finland
374= University of TRIESTE Italy
377 OKAYAMA University Japan
378= Universität REGENSBURG Germany
378= University of KENTUCKY United States
380 SUNG KYUN KWAN University Korea, South
381= YESHIVA University United States
381= University of MISSOURI United States
383= Technische Universität BRAUNSCHWEIG Germany
383= Leibniz Universität HANNOVER Germany
383= CONCORDIA University Canada
386= KUMAMOTO University Japan
386= NORTHEASTERN University United States
388= Università degli Studi di PAVIA Italy
388= Christian-Albrechts-Universität zu KIEL Germany
390 ISTANBUL Technical University Turkey
391 Université PARIS V - Descartes France
392 Universität MANNHEIM Germany
393 Universitat de VALENCIA Spain
394 University of SIENA Italy
395 University of INDONESIA Indonesia
396= Martin-Luther-Universität HALLE-WITTENBE... Germany
396= GEORGIA STATE University United States
398= SOGANG University Korea, South
398= National CENTRAL University Taiwan
398= University of the PHILIPPINES Philippines
Source: THES - QS World University Rankings
INFO, TIPS BEASISWA, FAQ - ADS
Hanya ada di http://www.milisbeasiswa.com/
===============================
CARI KERJA?
Gabung dengan milis vacancy. Kirim email kosong ke vacancy-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.
http://www.groups.yahoo.com/group/vacancy
===============================
INGIN KELUAR DARI MILIS BEASISWA?
Kirim email kosong ke beasiswa-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/beasiswa/
<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional
<*> To change settings online go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/beasiswa/join
(Yahoo! ID required)
<*> To change settings via email:
mailto:beasiswa-digest@yahoogroups.com
mailto:beasiswa-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
beasiswa-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar